telescopeѲptics.net          ▪▪▪▪                                                                               CONTENTS

APPENDIX: Telescope system specifications

                 D=diameter   f=f.l./D   K=conic   R=surface radius   S=separation   M=medium   A=air   RI=best image curvature   A4/A6=aspheric coefficients  T=tilt (deg.)

 NEWTONIAN  

D

f/

R1

K1

S1 

M1 

R2  

K2

T2

S2 

M2  

RI

1. Sphere  

6"

8.15

97.8

0

42

A

0

~45

6.9

A

-48.9

2. Paraboloid  

6"

8.15

97.8

-1

42

A

0

~45

6.9

A

-48.9

TWO-MIRROR

Dmm  

f/  

R1

 K1  

S1

M1

R2

K2

S2

M2

R3

K3

S3

M3

RI

1. Classical Cassegrain 

400

15

-2400

-1

-960

A

-600

-2.25

1200

A

-

-

-

-

-256

2. Classical Gregory  

400

15

-2400

-1

-1600

A

666.7

-0.444

2000.6

A

-

-

-

-

390

3. Aplanatic Cassegrain       

400

8

-2400

-1.135

-807.3

A

-1256.7

 -6.55  

1047.23

A

-

-

-

-

-412

4. Aplanatic Gregorian  

400

8

-1200

 -0.9828

-800

A

337

-0.5

1069.84

A

-

-

-

-

182

5. Aplanatic Gregorian  

400

8

-2400

-0.8825

-2060

A

1251

-0.27 

2293.95

A

-

-

-

-

780

6. Dall-Kirkham  

400

8

-2400

-0.5972

-791

A

-1309

0

1090.9

A

-

-

-

-

-690

7. Schwarzschild aplanat

200

3

-2666

-8.63

-756

A

951

2.5

261.7

A

-

-

-

-

 ∞

8. Couder anastigmatic aplanat

200

3

-4000

-15.8

-1200

A

694

-0.53

243

A

-

-

-

-

296

7. 3R Gregorian  

400

3

-1474

-0.428

-1069

A

1044

-6.55

1069

A

-1474

-0.428

1069

A

 -215

w/flattener: primary-to-1st-lens-surface -1166mm, R1=55, S1=-6(BK7),  R2=55, S2=-0.5(air), R3=0, S3=-2.5(BK7),  R4=77
#7 is 2-mirror 3-reflection system

THREE-MIRROR

Dmm

f/

R1

K1  

S1

M1 

R2

K2

S2

M2

R3 

K3

S3  

M3

RI

1. Paul-Baker  

300

3

-1800

-1

-625

A

-550

0

550

A

-550

-275

A

-900

2. Paul-Baker  

300

3

-1250

-1

-434

A

-381.94

-0.6651

550 

A

-550 

0

-275

A

3. FAA1  

300 

3

-2000  

-0.95  

-1088.2

A

-284

0

223.8

A

-331

0

-408.52

A

4. FA   

300

3.9

-2520  

-1

-1370.9

A

-362.9

0

284.8

A

-423.9

0

-529

A

5. FAA2  

304

3

-1189  

-0.806

-519.5

A

-206.5

0

700

A

-250

-0.4631

176.93

A

6. Cassegrain-Gregorian, 3A*   

300 

4.25

-1800

0  

-825

A

380

0

340

A

-380

-0.396

-565.16

A

333

7. Cassegrain-Gregorian, 3AA*

400

10.6

-2400

-0.727

-900

A

-2400

0

720

A

-465

-0.576

-850.29

A

-237

*folded; uses small flat in the focal zone of the primary  

TILTED

D 

f/

R1

K1

T1

S1

M1

R2

K2

T2

S2

M2

R3

K3

T3

S3

M3

RI

1. Stevick*  

8" 

11.7

188

-1 

3.1

-55.625  

A

-76.75

0

-5.346**

76.75

A

-76.75

0

-2.25

-38.575

A

-94**

*source: WinSpot    ** negative value is for counterclockwise tilt

REFRACTOR

Dmm

f/

R1

S1

M1

R2

S2

M2

R3

S3

M3

R4

S4

M4

RI

1. Fraunhofer doublet*  

100

15

911.25

13.7

BK7

-532

0

A

-538.9

10

F2

-2214

1487.9

A

-558

1. Apo doublet*  

100

10

478.75

18.52

S-FPL52

 -209.9

3.44

A

-209.6

10

 ZKN7

-1838.7

 972.34

A

-343

*source: ATMOS

SUBAPERTURE_
CAT'S

D

f/  

8R18  

8K1

S1-M1

88R288

K2

S2 -M2

R3

S3 -M3  

00R40  

0S4 -M4

80R508

S5-M5

R6

S6/M6

R7

S7/M7

RI

1. Tele-extender corrector, Newton

200mm

4/8.4

-1600

-1

-754 A

-660

-

-6 F2

39

-0.15 A

38

-4 BK7

-30

-81.9-A

-

-

-

-

-300

2. Menisc. coma corr.  (paraboloid)

200mm

4

-1600

-1

-604 A

107

-

-14 BK7

107

-196 A

-  

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

180

3. Menisc. sphere corr.  

200mm

5

-2000

0

-764 A  

89

-

-21.2 BK7

93.6

-250.9 A

-  

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

150

4. Jones-Bird,         (sphere)  

200mm

5.9

-1563

0

-610 A

 331.7  

-

-5 K7

-174.1

-0.6 A

-104

-6.6 F2

-178.1

-245.5 A

-

-

-

-

70

5. Jones-Bird, (paraboloid)

200mm

5.9

-1563

-1

-610 A

 1000  

-

-5 BK7

-92

-0.6 A

-85

-6.6 SSK2

-194

-187.6 A

-

-

-

-

100

6. Ross corrector  

200mm

4

-1600

-1**

-747.5 A

 -86.7  

-

-3 BK7

-40.3

-1.6 A

-146.7

-4 BK7

146.7

-46.2 A

-

-

-

-

7. Modified Ross  

200mm

4

-1612

-1**

-744.6 A

 -46.2  

-

-4.9 BK7

-32.2

-2.8 A

560

-2.8 BK7

102.3

-46.8 A

-

-

-

-

8. Split meniscus  

200mm

3.7

-1606

-1**

-742 A

 -46.5  

-

-2.7 BK7

-214

-0.4 A

-53

-2 BK7

-28

-50.4 A

-

-

-

-

9. Rosin astrograph 

10"

4

-90

-1.408

-40.77 A

-2.392

-

.35 SF11

-1.965  

.28 A

55.14

0.35 BK7

6.786

3 A

-

-

-

-

10. Sphere corrector  

200mm

5

-2000

0

-740 A

-500

-

-6 K11

0

-2- 

500

-5 K11

0

-247.2 A

-

-

-

-

11. Wynne

625mm

3.3

-3750

-1

-1693 A

-71.6

-

-4.9 NBK7

-93.3

-46.4 A

-152

-2 NBK7

-56.5

-104.3 A

-103.74

-6 NBK7

0

-34.32A

12. All-spherical
    Gregorian

200mm 

17.9

-1600

0

-1067 A

440

0

260 A

166

8 BK7

-200

2.7 A

-166

5 BK6

200

894.5 A

-

-

13. CCass. w/field corrector A

250mm

10

-2000

-1

-657 A

-1137

-5.15

718 A

0

5 BK7

121.5 

2.5 A

239

5 BK7

-239

139 A

-

-

14. CCass. w/field corrector B

400mm

8.8

-2790

-1

-912 A

-1606

-5.365

1015 A

-615

8 N-FK5

- 322 

1 A

96.6

7 N-BK7

80.8

181.5 A

-

-

15. Cass w/sph. secondary C

400mm

8.8

-3160

-1

-954 A

-2290

0

590 A

577

15 N-BK7

369 

8 A

-720

10 N-BK7

-430

771.8 A

 

 

16. Cass w/sph. secondary D

400mm

5.9

-2400

-1

-721 A

-1954

0

452 A

0

7 BK7

367 

4.5 A

0

8 BK7

-361

400 A

-2860

4 BK7

17. DK with integrated corr. A

300mm

8

-2168

-0.81

-682.4 A

-1464

0

524.6 A

0

4 BK7

258  

3.1 A

0

5 BK7

-258

362 A

-

-

19. DK with integrated corr. B

300mm

7.6

-2130

-0.69

-658 A

-1546

0

639 A

-117

7 BK7

88  

11 A

-193

6 BK7

-131

205.3 A

-

-

20. DK with integrated corr. C

300mm

8

-2880

-0.682

-795 A

-3290

0

877 A

592

9 BK7

-592 

1 A

124.5

6 BK7

82

169.6 A

-

-

21. DK with integrated corr. D

300mm

7.7

-1616

-0.705

-538 A

-854

0

520 A

0

5 BK7

131 

5.5 A

0

6 BK6

-131

130 A

-630

5 BK7

22. RC w/field corrector L

400mm

8.1

-2256

-1.123

-760 A

-1138

-5.74

944 A

0

8 BK7

-111 

6.8 A

-96

6.4 BK7

0

89.2 A

-

-

23. RC with field corrector R

400mm

8.2

-2800

-1.23

-882 A

-1827

-9.9

1022 A

165

10 BK7

177

2 A

96

9 BK7

82

152 A

-

-

24. Field-Maksutov

200mm

10

-1200

0

-422 A

130

0

-16 BK7

133.5

-2 A

-500  

2 A

133.5

16 BK7

130

554.8 A

-

-

-300

25. Klevtsov

200mm

10

-1200

0

-403 A

-73.8

0

-13.5 BK7

-68

-8 A

-910 

-9 BK7

-550

9 BK7

-910

8 A

-68

13.5 BK7

-160

-73.8

543.5 A

15. Gregorian with sub-aperture Schmidt corr.

8in 

11.4

R1

K1

S1/M1

R2

K2

S2/M2

R3

 S3/M3

A4 **

A6

A8

R4

S4/M4

RI

-33.33

0

-21.67 A

8.563

-0.34

5.066 A

0

0.166 BK7

0.00371

1.36E-5

4.374E-6

-150

22.72 A

6.2

16. Gregorian with sub-aperture Schmidt corr.

12in 

11.2

R1

K1

S1/M1

R2

K2

S2/M2

R3

A4

A6

A8

S3/M3

R4

A4

A6

A8

S4/M4

R5

S5/M5

RI

-50

0

-32.5 A

12.845

-0.3

7.6 A

125

-
0.001494

9.6E-7

6.4E-7

0.175BK7

-125

0.001494

-9.6E-7

-6.4E-7

0.35 BAF51

0

32.99 A

9.5

 

CATADIOPTRIC  DIALYTES

Dmm

f/  

8R18  

S1

M1

R2

S2

M2

R3

S3

M3

R

0S4 

0M4  

R5

S5

M5

R6

S6

M6

R7

S7

M7

RI

1. Hamiltonian, f/12

150

12

812

15

BK7

6228

921

A

-562

10

F2

-1482

-10

F2

-562

-935.3

A

-

-

-

-

-

-

2500

2. Hamiltonian, f/7.6 

150

7.6

777

15

BK7

4660

827

A

-561

11

F2

-1142

-10

F2

-561

-583.7

A

-

-

-

-

-

-

2000

3. Hamiltonian w/corrector

150

7.4

808

15

BK7

 6195 

900

A

-560

10

F2

-1470

-10

F2

-560

-800

A

-70

-7

F2

0

-38.5

A

300

4. Honders-Riccardi, f/3.7

300

3.7

4315

32

BK7

-7360

927.6

A

-1268

32

BK7

-2109

-32

BK7

-1268

-945.2

A

-332

-15

BK7

-7360

-131.3

A

5. Honders-Riccardi, f/7.4

300

7.4

8630

22

BK7

-14700

1860

A

-2560

20  

BK7 

-4210

-20

BK7

-2560

-1940

A

-670

-5

BK7

-14,000

-271.4

A

4. Busack  triplet, f/3.7

300

3.7

3988

25

BK7

-9882

959

A

-1322

33

BK7

-2148

-33

BK7

-1322

-959

A

-344

-33

BK7

-9000

-131.3

A

5. Busack Cassegrain  f/3.7

300

3.7

1110

22

BK7

2388

388

A

-999

25  

BK7 

-1477

-25

BK7

-999

-366

A

-2222

414

A

211

11

BK7

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

R6

S6

M6

 

311

130.3

A

SCHMIDT CORRECTOR

Dmm

f/

R1

S1

M1

R2

A4**

A6

NZ

S2

M2

R3

K3

S3

M3

R4

K4

S4

M4

RI

1..Schmidt_camera    

200  

2.4

 4  

BK7

-60,800

5.36E-10

8.9E-16

0.866

960

-960

0

-478.03

A

-

-

-

-

-486

2. Schmidt camera

200

2.4

4

BK7

-96,800

5.39E-10

8.9E-16

0.707

960

A

-960

0

-478.75

A

-

-

-

-

-478

3. Vaisala-Schmidt

200

2

5

BK7

-54,000

9.27E-10

2.16E-15

0.707

800

A

-800

0

-394.5

A

-133

0

K11

A

4. Schmidt camera

200

2.6

4

BK7

-114,000

4.45E-10

6.6E-16

0.707

1024

A

-1024 

0

-510.8

A

-  

-

-  

-

-516

5. Wright camera

200 

2.4

5

BK7

-29,600

1.07E-9

1.3E-15

0.866

80

A

-960

1

-475.96

A 

-

-  

-

-  

-478

6. Schmidt-Newton

200

5

BK7

-440,000

1.18E-10

2.5E-17

0.707

700

A

-1600 

0

-799.2

A

-  

-

-

-

-2160

7. SCT (Fig. 110a)

200

10

5

BK7

-76,000

6.72E-10

3.7E-16

0.707

325

A

-800

0

-300

A

-250

0

473.79 

A

-230

8. SCT Fig. 137a / 132d

200

10

5

BK7

-160,000

3.13E-10

6E-17

0.707

375

A

-1000

0

-350

A

-400  

0

587.2

A

-360

9. SCT (aplanatic)  

300

8

5

BK7

-100,000

2.28E-10

3.76E-17

0.707

455

A

-1200

0

-432

A

-443

-1.2

664.61

A

 -260

10. SCT (Fig. 140a)    

200

10

5

BK7

 -285,000  

1.8E-10

6E-17

0.707

450 

A

-1200

0

-420

A

-510

0

604.46

A

-440

11. Schmidt-Baker, long

300

3.3

7.5

BK7

-133,000

1.637E-10

1.1E-16

0.707

1357

A

-1200

0

-360

A

-1200

0

396.1

A

12. Concentric SC camera

300

4.7

7.5

BK7

-152,000

1.484E-10

9E-17

0.707

1200

A

-1200

0

-360

A

-840

0

553.34

A

-1400

13. Flat-field SC camera

300

3.3

7.5

BK7

-140,000

1.61E-10

1.1E-16

0.707

1345

A

-1200

0

-360

A

-1140

0

410.47

A

14. Schmidt-Baker, short

300

5

7.5

BK7

-140,000

1.622E-10

1.27E-16

0.707

900

A

-1800

1.8

-540

A

-1800

16.5

591.7

A

*NZ=neutral zone   **E, or Exp indicates the needed power of 10 to produce very large, or very small number; example: 2E-9=2x10-9=2x1/109

MENISCUS CORRECTOR

Dmm

f/

R1

S1

M1

R2

S2

M2

R3

K3

S3

M3

R4

K4

S4

M4

RI

1. Maksutov camera

200

2.6

-224

20.7

BK7

-236.176

631

A

-1063

0

-545.144

A

 -

-

-

-

-584

2. Maksutov-Newton *

204

4  

-307.3

20

S-BSL7

-319.053

643

A

-1627

0

-830.42

A

-

-

-

-

-1780

3. MCT (Fig. 114b)

200

10

-248.2

25

BK7

-262.9

370

A

-1000

0

-370

-374

0

587.89

A

-390

4. MCT Fig. 140e / 132e

200

10

-282.15

25

BK7

-296.7

444

A

-1200

0

-444

A

-478

0

577.74

A

-460

5. MC2.9 (Fig. 115)

200

2.9

-251.4

25

BK7

-266

792

A

-1200

0

-616.228

A

-

-

-

-

-660

6. MC4.9 (Fig. 115)

200

4.9

-357.5

20

BK7

-369.2

850

A

-2000

0

-1018.83

A

-

-

-

-

-1960

7. MCT (Fig.119a)

200

17

-272.4

25

BK7

-287

495

A

-1200

0

-495

A

-287

0

698.9

A

-280

8. MCT (Fig. 119b)

200

10

-283.7

25

BK7

-298.3

440

-1200

0

-438

A

-495

0

597.9

A

-480

*flat omitted;  source: ATMOS

HOUGHTON CORRECTOR 

Dmm

f/

R1

S1

M1

_R2_

S2

M2

R3

S3

M3

R4

S4

M4

_R5_

S5

M5

R6

S6

M6

RI

1. HC camera (plano)  

200

2.5

767

12

BK7

0

7

A

-767

5

BK7

0

250

A

-1000 

-497.7

A

-

-

-

2. Houghton-Newtonian*  

200

5

1525 

12

BK7

0

4

A

-1525

8

BK7

0

850 

A

-2000

-998.4

A

-

-

-

-3000

3. HCT(aplanatic Fig. 132a)  

200

10

685

20

BK7

-789

1.5

A

-685

8

BK7

789

375

A

-1000

-348.1

A

-400

578.57

A

-360

4. HCT (Fig.132b)

200

10

2140

14.5

BK7

-1190

2.5

A

-766

10

BK7

0

365

A

-1000

-360

A

-372

554.53

A

-320

5. HCT (Fig.132c)

200

10

884

12.1

BK7

0

5.8

A

-884

8

BK7

0

375

A

-1000

-350

A

-400

581.3

A

-360

6. HCT (aplanatic Fig. 133c)

200

9.9

964

14

BK7

-1265

1.4

-964

5

BK7

 1265

430

A

-1200

-415.4

A

-527.5

597.48

A

-440

7. HCT**  Fig. 133d

200

10

1094

14.5

BK7

-1930

2

A

-1094

10

BK7

1930

420 

A

-1200

-413.7

A

-530.3

611.41

A

-447

8. HCT (plano Fig. 136a)  

200

9.9

884

12.1

BK7

0

5.8  

A

-884

8

BK7 

 0  

375

A

-1000

-350 

A

-400

581.3

A

-360

9. HCT camera (Fig. 136b)  

200

5  

1000

13

BK7

0

7

A

-1000

BK7

0

253

A

-1000

-253

A

-1000

484 

A

-700

10. HCT camera (plano)  

200

4.7

953

13

BK7

0

7

A

-953

8

BK7

0

300

A

-1000

-280

A

-940

409.5

A

-600

11. HCT (plano Fig. 136c)  

200

8.2

885

12.4

BK7

0

6

A

-885

8

BK7

0

370

A

-1000

-350

A

-430

483

A

-400

12. HCT achr.  

200

10

685

20

BK7

-783

1.5

A

-685

8

BK8

783

375

A

-1000

-348.1

A

-400

578.57

A

-360

13. HCT achr.  

200

10

682

20

BK7

-784

3.5

A

-682

8

BK8

784

375

A

-1000

-348.1

A

-400

578.57

A

-360

14. HCT (Fig. 140b)

200

10

1063

12.1

BSL7Y

0

4.8

A

 -1063

8

BK7

 0

450

A

-1200

-420

A

-512

594

A

-440

15. HCT (Fig. 140c)**

200

10 

2327

12

BSL7Y

-784

2.2

A

-1646

9

BK7

0

420

A

-1200

-413.7

A

-530.3

615.37

A

-447

16. HCT (Fig. 140d)

200

9.8

975

14

BSL12

-1265 

2.5

A

-975

9

PK3

1265

430

A

-1200

-415

A

-540

597.62

A

-460

17. HCT (designing)

200

10.5

739

15

BK7

-851

4

-739

8

BK7

 851

420

A

-1200

-403

A

-418

565.94

A

-440

18. HCT Fig.138/139  

200

9.75

940

12.1 

BK7

0

6

A

-940

9

BK7

0

375

A

-1000

-350

A

-400

 150 

A

 

corrector:

326

5

BK7

0

1.5

A  

-326

4

BK7

0

417.18

A

-  

-

-

-

-

-

-550

19. HC camera Fig. 128a  

200

2.5

783

12

BK7

0

10

A

-783

8

BK7

0

380

A

-1000

-390

A

 

 

 

 

corrector:

-783

-5

BK7

0

-2

A

783

-4  

BK7

0

-99.32

A

-

-

-

-

-

-

-1000

20. HC camera Fig. 128b  

200

2.5

781

12

BK7

0

 8.6

A

-781

8

BK7

0

415

A  

-1000

-430

A

 

 

 

 

corrector:

-405

-5  

BK7

0

-2

A

405

-4

BK7

0

-59.46

A

-

-

-

-

-

-

-480

21. HC camera Fig. 129A

200

4.3

914

12

BSL22

0

17

A

-914

 9

BK7

0

326  

A

-970

-274

A

-970

286

A

 

corrector:

397

7

BK7

0

2

A

-397

5

BK7

0

69.33  

A

-

-

-

-

-

-

22. HC camera Fig. 129B

200

4.3

900

15

BK7

0

15

A

-900

10

BK7

0

480

A

-900

-425

A

-900

245

A

 

corrector:

-97.5

7.8

BK7

-100.88

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

128.12

A

23. HC f/3  Fig.126b  

200

3

940

12

BK7

-1200

5

A

-940

8

BK7

1200

360  

A

-1200

-598.5

A

-

-

-

24. HC f/3  Fig.126a  

200

3

922

12

BK7

0

5.5

A

-922

10

BK7

0

300  

A

-1000

-598.45

A

-

-

-

25. Houghton-Newtonian  

200

5

1614

12

BK7

-5370

5

A

-1614

8

BK7

5370

800

A

-2000

-998.26

A

-

-

-

*flatt omitted    ** source: ATMOS        

TELESCOPE_EYEPIECES

f(mm)

FD*

R1**

S1 

M1

R2   

S2

M2

R3 

S3

M3

R4

S4

M4

R5

S5

M5

R6

S6

M6

RI

1. Huygens

20

-5.8

18

3

BK7

0

20

A

9

2

BK7

0

3.1

A

-

-

-

-

-

-

18

2. Ramsden  

20

0

4

BK7

-14 

18 

A

14

2.5

BK7

0

8

A

-

-

-

-

-

-

60

3. Monocentric  

20

8.3

11.6

6.3

F2

5.3

10.6

BK7

-5.3 

6.3

F2

-11.6

9

A

-

-

-

-

-

-

18

4. Kellner  

20

5.8

0

3.8

BAK2

-17

16

A

14

6

BAK2

-10

1.4

 F4

0

9.5

A

-

-

-

100

5. König  

astigmatic

20

12.9

-31.9

1.5

SF4

15.2

6.1

SK10

-18.2

0.1

A

20.5

3.8

SK2

64.6

21.3

A

-  

-

-

230

comatic

20

12.9

-42.5

1.9

SF4

15.8

5

SK10

-19.3

0.13

A

20.8

6

SK2

86.6

7.6

A

-

-

-

-36

6. Erfle  

20

11.6

-55

1.7 

SF12

22.6

6.6

PSK3

-30

0.1

A

41

6.6

FK5

-41

0.1

A

19

6.6

PSK3

   

 R7 /S7 /M7  -  R8 /S8 /M8  -29/1.7/SF10  - 166/ 15/A

100

7. Abbe  

20

11.2

26.7

7.1

BAF5

-16 

1.8

SF14

16

7.1

SK7

-24.9

0.1

A

26.7

4.45

SF10

0

16.4

A

60

8. Plössl  

20

14.3

0

1.8

SF19

18.4

7.4

SK11

-19.3

0.1

A

19.3

6.4

SK11

-18.4

1.8

SF19

0

 15.6

A

70

9. Achromat pair  

20

14.7

0

2

F4

19

6

BaK2

-19

0.1

A

19

6

BaK2

-19

2

F4

0

18

A

10. Single lens pair  

20

20.2

0

3

BK7

-21

0.1

A

21

3

BK7

0

20

A

        

  

   

     

  

-

24

*Front distance: field lens front surface to objective's image separation (last separation S is the eye relief)    **Front field lens radius

Human Eye: Optical model

Dmm

f/

R1

S1

M1

R2

S2

M2

R3

S3

M3

R4

S4

M4

R5

S5

M5

R6

S6

M6

RI

  

1-7

20-3

7.3

0.45

Silica

5.6

2.8

Water

0* 

0  

Water

500**

0.6

Pyrex

2.6

4

Silica

-6.3

~20

Water

-12.5

*aperture stop    **cylinder

Home  |  Comments